Written on Thursday, 22 December 2011 12:25
We missed this snippet of news the first time around because we were out in the field on assignment and doing valuable pre-season reconnaisance elsewhere. So we've only had it brought to our attention in the last week.
It concerns new St Kilda coach Scott Watters and his Circle of Trust - or, as it's been called elsewhere, the Magic Circle or Watters' Wheel.
Essentially, this revolutionary new coaching technique involves players gathering in a circle, linking arms, looking each other in the eye, chanting incantations by the light of a full moon and offering up sacrifices to the Gods. No, I made that last bit up.
But the first part would seem to be true: before every training session, the St Kilda players will form a circle (see picture, above) and talk about what they're going to do in the upcoming session. After their training run, they link up and do the same thing again, this time reviewing their work on the track.
Watters apparently employed the bonding technique in his time as coach of Subiaco in the WAFL and says it is about players facing up to each other.
''In a lot of team sports, it's about trust,'' he said. ''There's a lot of symbolism with a circle. They get the opportunity to look each other in the eye, set their goals for training and then, immediately post-training, they get the chance to reflect on what they've just done.
''Within that opportunity different players have different opportunities to say what's on their mind ... It's a sharing time. They get an opportunity to communicate."
Designated players speak during the huddle. ''It is about maximising every minute,'' Watters said. ''We want a minute-by-minute culture at our footy club where we're taking every opportunity. That just gives them a chance to set goals and reset goals. They're connected. They've got to stay connected as a group.''
Watters said the St Kilda players had embraced the changes made after the departure of long-term coach Ross Lyon at the end of the 2011 season, including the huddle. ''It's another one of the things they've attacked from day one. They feel like they're getting something out of it, and that's important.''
Now call me old-fashioned, call me a dinosaur even, but I reckon I've heard it all now.
''Symbolism of a circle'', ''Looking each other in the eye'', ''Sharing time'', ''Minute by minute culture''. What is this - some kind of crackpot cult or a footy club?
How would Tony Lockett, Geoff Cunningham, Carl Ditterich, Robbie Muir and Greg Burns have reacted to all that modern-age claptrap?
The only ''symbolism of a circle'' they were interested in was their meat pie after training. The only time Muir would have had his arms around a teammate's shoulder was in the process of throttling him for the ball. And ''sharing time''? That was when Plugger, Danny Frawley and Joffa Cunningham piled into the same ute from Ballarat for the trip to Moorabbin.
Now he's a lovely bloke, 'Smurf' Watters. One of the game's good guys. Very stiff to miss out on West Coast's 1992 premiership. And clearly he comes well-regarded after his stints at Subiaco and Collingwood.
But which coaching manual did he get this mumbo-jumbo from?
It's the kind of new-age gibberish that gnarly old-timers might listen to and then, with their face screwed up, say: eh?
In fact, that rumbling sound you hear in the distance could well be Jock McHale, Norm Smith and Allan Jeans rolling in their graves.
Training at Collingwood in the 1920s involved rolling around in the mud, eating a bucket of nails then retiring to the sheds to have a fag and sink a keg of Melbourne Bitter - each. Training at Hawthorn in the 1970s under John Kennedy was only marginally more enlightened: players had to get through a plate of Bobby Yeoman's curried sausages first, before tackling the keg.
Now, players are doing ring-a-ring-a-rosy, not just after training but before as well. Good grief.
Somewhere between Yeoman's curried sausages, 'Whale' Roberts dragging on a durry at half-time and Denis Pagan's occasional North Melbourne training sessions at the pub, we've missed something.
Is this the caring, sharing, warm and fuzzy approach that the modern AFL coach has to adopt to get the best out of his Gen Y and Z players? Maybe it is. Maybe we are hopelessly behind the times. Maybe it'll work a treat.
If Watters' Magic Circle can indeed conjure a miracle in 2012, we'll be first in the queue to congratulate him. As things stand, though, we'll remain sceptical and, on the eve of Christmas, resolutely Scrooge-like.
Latest articles from Charles Happell
-
Demons' problems run a lot deeper than the coach
Sunday, 20 May 2012 14:13
Mark Neeld is in the gun after eight straight losses but CHARLES HAPPELL says the…
-
The day Kenny Deans lit up Arden St
Thursday, 17 May 2012 15:01
CHARLES HAPPELL came across some correspondence this week which revealed just how much football, and…
-
Boomer or bust
Sunday, 13 May 2012 17:38
CHARLES HAPPELL reflects on an AFL round where the underdogs bit back, the Suns were…
Mark Neeld is in the gun after eight straight losses but CHARLES HAPPELL says the…
CHARLES HAPPELL came across some correspondence this week which revealed just how much football, and…
CHARLES HAPPELL reflects on an AFL round where the underdogs bit back, the Suns were…

Circle of Trust. Leap of Faith


If the home crowd has everything to do with the free kick count, then why don't Fremantle (with a far more feral and loud fan base) get accorded the same...
Cheers Will, as always. I don't think Thompson is necessarily the best player in the competition. At present he is definately the most consistent. It was great watching him work...
Wow, normally if people put that many thought to paper half end up a crock of warm bovine excrement but this was gold all the way through. Probably mostly right,...
Improved fitness levels will have a greater impact on their on-field performance than anything else IMO. Let Dave Misson work his special magic on them for the remainder of the...
William Thomson has got it right - a whole new culture is required and Neeld must be backed to instill it . Melbourne players now have to ask what they...
No doubt attitude flows down to the younger players. Someone needs to set the tone because Moloney, Sylvia, Davey and Green are setting poor examples. Look at the impact Judd had...
"The finger of blame shouldn’t point elsewhere other than a senior brigade that have seemingly reacted badly to a new approach and are playing like Fuchsias, or an administration that...