Written on Thursday, 18 March 2010 08:41
Ten Things We Don't Want to See or Hear This Season
1. Traffic-Copping
This seems to be mandatory for anybody who has just kicked a behind: this person suddenly seems to take over the organisational duties of the forward-50 defence for the kick-in, waving their arms, pointing to players, calling out to team-mates and generally doing their best to look as if setting up the defence is their job. Stop it. Everyone knows what to do - the only reason they might be momentarily out of position is that they should have been getting into position for a bounce, had you not missed a simple goal.
2. Motioning players into position
Nathan Buckley, who started this, has a lot to answer for: the ball carrier now motions to his teammates with his hands, to tell them where to lead, in order for the delivery process to begin. Can it. Your teammates know where to go. They lead, then you deliver it to where they're headed. Players trying to direct their teammates in this fashion invariably aren't seeing potential interceptors of the kick, or potential tacklers.
3. Deliberate out-of-bounds
This is the worst rule on the statute book by a mile. Very dubious interpretations of it are given every game, but what makes it so stupid is that players are allowed to walk over the boundary line with the ball a hundred times a game - you can't get much more deliberate than that.
4. Commentator bias
We no longer have to listen on TV to Eddie's admirable - but ultimately almost self-parodying - determination to be professionally even-handed: remember how, if a team got a run on against the ‘Pies, he would inject excitement into his voice, and say something like "and it's another one, they're running away with this," when you just knew how much his guts were churning. But there are still tweaks we can make: like keeping Dennis Cometti away from non-Victorian teams, Robert Walls away from teams he played for or coached; and Bruce McAvaney away from Nic Naitanui.
5. Phrases gone to the graveyard of cliché
Please, let's not hear about a team having "come to play" or being "up and about." Sheesh. And while we're on this subject, Australian Rules football does not have a position, nor even a playing role, that will ever justify the use of the term "quarterback". Nor does it have a "post-season": it has finals.
6. Shrinking-violet umpires whose feelings get hurt
This almost decided a Grand Final. And he misunderstood the gesture! Enough said.
7. Geographical and sequential influences on free kicks
Where an offence occurs - for instance, in which 50 - should not govern whether a free kick is paid. Nor should what happened with the decision before that, and the one before that. They swear it does not: we're not stupid.
8. Travel excuses
Fans are sick of this. Flying for an hour or three in Australia is not an excuse for leaving all basic standards of accountability, intensity and execution skill at home. AFL has to grow up, here. Look at the nation's Super 14 Rugby teams: they have to play in the sleet in Dunedin, fly to Africa, play a game in heat at sea level and then in the chill of altitude or vice versa - and they're expected to win them all. Get over it! And furthermore - in AFL travel is always viewed through the prism of the poor, put-upon Victorian teams. No-one ever seems to ask how the real frequent flyers of the AFL handle it.
9. Gold Coast's jumper
There is still a year to go. For all of our sakes, send this abomination back to the drawing board. After all, it took Port Adelaide 12 years to get it right.
10. References to the WA "durr-by"
Just accept it, boys and girls, you got it wrong - as if the Group 1 horse races, the English soccer and cricket team and the actual usage you're copying (as in English soccer games between local rivals) didn't exist. It's funny how words in English can sound differently to how they look, isn't it? Repeat after me: it's "dar-by". Yes, I know the Americans pronounce it the way you do, but that's their excuse: they're Americans. We're not.
Latest articles from James Dunn
-
You bet I'm excited!
Monday, 28 March 2011 21:15
Lifelong Essendon fan and BPL columnist JAMES DUNN can't contain his excitement at the James…
-
Can curse of Zimbabwe strike again?
Saturday, 19 February 2011 22:56
The start to Australia's World Cup campaign on Monday has worrying echoes of the same tournament…
-
Ashes autopsy: picking over the corpse
Thursday, 30 December 2010 16:06
JAMES DUNN, BPL's emeritus professor of cricket, has got the results back from the lab -…
Lifelong Essendon fan and BPL columnist JAMES DUNN can't contain his excitement at the James…
The start to Australia's World Cup campaign on Monday has worrying echoes of the same tournament…
JAMES DUNN, BPL's emeritus professor of cricket, has got the results back from the lab -…

Ten Things We Can Do Without


If the home crowd has everything to do with the free kick count, then why don't Fremantle (with a far more feral and loud fan base) get accorded the same...
Cheers Will, as always. I don't think Thompson is necessarily the best player in the competition. At present he is definately the most consistent. It was great watching him work...
Wow, normally if people put that many thought to paper half end up a crock of warm bovine excrement but this was gold all the way through. Probably mostly right,...
Improved fitness levels will have a greater impact on their on-field performance than anything else IMO. Let Dave Misson work his special magic on them for the remainder of the...
William Thomson has got it right - a whole new culture is required and Neeld must be backed to instill it . Melbourne players now have to ask what they...
No doubt attitude flows down to the younger players. Someone needs to set the tone because Moloney, Sylvia, Davey and Green are setting poor examples. Look at the impact Judd had...
"The finger of blame shouldn’t point elsewhere other than a senior brigade that have seemingly reacted badly to a new approach and are playing like Fuchsias, or an administration that...