Written on Wednesday, 30 November 2011 10:58
(Chris Forster is a cricket fan and BPL Citizen Journalist)
Ricky Ponting must see out the summer as a member of the Australian cricket side. No ifs or buts about it.
With Shaun Marsh currently sidelined with an injury, there is no ideal candidate to replace Australia's greatest batsman since Don Bradman. It's easy for people to call for Ponting to be sacked in order to introduce new blood into the side, but the new blood has to warrant being selected. There is no point selecting a player based solely on youth. The player's form has to justify their selection otherwise the baggy green will lose all of the prestige it once carried.
While Ponting may be struggling for form, there aren't a whole lot of players in the state game that are banging down the door demanding to be selected in the national side. Only New South Wales blaster David Warner and Tasmanian Ed Cowan have shown any real consistency at the crease this season, and neither of them are middle-order batsmen.
Callum Ferguson, who not so long ago was being groomed as the future of Australian cricket, has struggled for form with South Australia this season, while George Bailey and Steve Smith both failed to impress with the bat for the Australia A side in their recent tour match against New Zealand.
One suggestion has been to move Shane Watson down the order to limit his work load and bring in a new opening batsman. While this may work in theory, I would advise against it purely on the basis that Watson is an opening batsman and he belongs at the top of the order. He opens the batting in all forms of the game and that is where he is most damaging.
If Watson needs to shoulder less work, then he should not be bowling as many overs as he currently is. It seems to me that whenever Watson is breaking down with back spasms and hamstring injuries, it is when he is in running in to bowl not when he is at the crease with the bat. The solution should be to bowl Watson less, not move him down the batting order.
One thing Ponting brings to the table that simply can't be replaced is experience.
He has been a mainstay in the Australian side for over a decade and obviously been a highly successful captain. In fact his run as Australian skipper was so successful that he won more Test matches than any other captain in history.
And with Michael Clarke only recently taking over the reins as skipper, having someone with Ponting's experience to call upon in difficult situations will only benefit Clarke's growth.
It's all well and good to call for Ponting to step down and make way for someone else, but I ask you this: Who has been playing well enough on a consistent level in order to dethrone one of the greatest batsmen of the modern era?
Latest articles from Citizen Journalists
-
50-metre fiasco
Wednesday, 23 May 2012 08:36
LES ZIGOMANIS wants the AFL to adjust the rigid application of its 50-metre penalty rule…
-
Neeld should be backed to cast out Demons
Monday, 21 May 2012 20:15
Mark Neeld should not be held responsible for Melbourne's woes, argues WILLIAM THOMSON, rather he…
-
Jurrah selection brings AFL into disrepute
Saturday, 19 May 2012 09:59
Citizen Journalist MATT POYNTING feels strongly about the selection of Melbourne's Liam Jurrah while awaiting…
LES ZIGOMANIS wants the AFL to adjust the rigid application of its 50-metre penalty rule…
Mark Neeld should not be held responsible for Melbourne's woes, argues WILLIAM THOMSON, rather he…
Citizen Journalist MATT POYNTING feels strongly about the selection of Melbourne's Liam Jurrah while awaiting…

In defence of Ricky


Call me perceptive, but I'm getting get the distinct feeling you two boys aren't big fans of Ricky ... Look forward to the fallout if NSW go one down after tonight's match.
Too true, they have been competitive in a lot of first quarters this season, and then seem to drop off.. they need time to train and then learn how to...
Too trues - they
Great concept, Murray - would love to read this every week! My two cents: 1. Will Majak Daw ever play a senior match for the Kangaroos? Yes, but only once...
It was, but so too was the endeavour. There were a lot of occasions where Melbourne players simply didn't go in to win the footy. That's inexcusable.
Re recruiting: I think the question is more interesting if it is asked the other way around... Would Nic Naitanui be as good if he taken at number 1? Michael...
If the home crowd has everything to do with the free kick count, then why don't Fremantle (with a far more feral and loud fan base) get accorded the same...